So they asked me if I wanted to play checkers. It was clear from watching a couple games
that I was going to be in serious trouble.
I've played a lot of checkers, but not with "queens" that can
move and jump unlimited straight-line spaces with possible 90 degree jump turns
at the end of each jump. Did you get
that? Me either, and that's why I was
worried. I actually won two out of three
games, mostly on blind luck. Following
my Dad's poker-playing advice, I quit while I was ahead.
Trying to explain my work here is just as frustrating as
trying to explain how Colombian checkers are played. You need to try it yourself. In Las Pavas, where I was the past week, the
game is framed generally as the small farmer good guys against the
multinational palm oil bad guys. But
after the sun went down on Thursday night one or two of the palm oil workers
living in "the big house" next to the community's temporary shelters
started heaving bricks over the fence and onto our corrugated metal roofs. Insults
were thrown along with the bricks. Maybe
they were drunk. It was loud. You couldn't see who was doing it. It was scary, but there wasn't much risk of
bodily harm as far as I could see. It
went on sporadically for nearly two hours.
It felt more personal than a land dispute. How it ended up is not today's story.
There is a history of bad feelings between the palm oil
employees and the agricultural cooperative, ASOCAB, that comprises the Las
Pavas community. The most direct threats
and assaults have come from the employees, who are mostly campesinos that live
nearby with their families and see a potential court decision against the palm
oil company as a threat to their economic future and the fault of ASOCAB. Whether this is true or not is not relevant. The point is that they believe this to be
true, and they feel it perversely unjust that all these international visitors,
including gringos like me, are working against them. Conflicts are anchored in what people
believe to be true.
It is easy for us to paint the palm oil company and the
political system weighted toward investment in large companies as the
bullies. At the same time, we need to
acknowledge that even if the courts decide tomorrow in favor of ASOCAB, a local
conflict will remain between alienated neighbors. It will have no reason to subside if we keep
handling it the same way we are at present.
Non-violent activism can also produce unanticipated
"blowback". Just like losing my queens in the checker
game, I wonder what else we're not seeing on the horizon.